Knowledge

Why do Egyptologists continue to denounce the Exodus as fictional despite the amount of archaeological evidence?

Nothing about the Exodus adds up archeologically.

  1. No contemporary Egyptian records, such as papyrus or monuments, mention the plagues, the death of a Pharaoh’s army in the sea, or a massive slave population. And there are records of the food rations for the men (who were not slaves) who built the pyramids and other monuments.
  2. The story’s timeline does not align well with known historical periods, and the estimated size of the escaping population (>2 million) is deemed unrealistic for that era.
  3. Surveys in the Sinai Peninsula have failed to find evidence of large, long-term, nomadic camps from the timeframe in question. Sustaining millions of people and their livestock in a desert for four decades would require massive infrastructure for water and sanitation that isn’t supported by the geography or archaeological record.
  4. How do more than 2 million people wander for 40 years lost in a desert that a reasonably fit person can hike across in two days? There were not even two million Egyptians living at the time.
  5. The text mentions cities and locations, such as Pithom and Ramesses, that do not correspond to the era in which the event is typically placed. They were build long AFTER the Exodus supposedly took place.

As the old lady said in the commercial, “Where’s the beef?”


I hate to sound like a “me too”…

However, the reason Egyptologists, as well as other archaeologists, continue to say that the exodus appears to be fictional is that there is NO archaeological evidence to support that it ever happened.

According to the story around 2 MILLION Jews spent forty years wandering around a patch of desert that should have taken an average person about a week to walk across.

Yet…

  • There is ZERO evidence of that area being occupied by such a large group of people around that point in history.
  • The Egyptians, who kept lots of excellent records, made NO NOTE WHATSOEVER of a slave revolt, or of a large groups of slaves leaving, at that point in history.
  • From the actual numbers it seems unlikely that such a large number of Jewish slaves even lived in Egypt… let alone escaped Egypt.
  • As I understand it, at the time the exodus was SUPPOSED to have taken place, the DESTINATION was also under Egyptian control… so the supposed route itself simply leads from one Egyptian territory to another at that point in history.

I believe the current theory is that, if it happened at all, “the exodus” was a MUCH SMALLER event than described, and has been “inflated”… probably as a way to provide the new Jewish cultural group with an impressive “origin story”.

Related Posts

Why was the Moskva sunk so easily in spite of her considerable AA defense systems?

Moskva on paper had decent air defenses, but the hardware was all Cold War era stuff, not upgraded and possibly not even working. That thing that looks like an…

Why do US Navy Nimitz-class and Ford-class aircraft carriers have cut outs near the bow that makes the deck shaped like a wine bottle instead of just a big rectangle with more parking space?

Those are not Cutouts. What you are looking at is the Angled Deck. It allows the Navy to conduct simultaneous Launch and recovery operations. Planes can be taking…

What is located on the bottom floor of an aircraft carrier?

I served aboard USS ABRAHAM LINCOLN (CVN72) as a machist mate a-gang. The lower and lowest decks are where the machinery spaces are. Additonally, there are fuel tanks…

Why is ‘double tapping’ by military personnel banned/illegal?

In Vietnam, as a tank driver, I remember some action near the Cambodian border in an area we called The Elephant Ear because on a map, it resembled…

What happened to all the “flak” shot at planes during war? Did it drop harmlessly to earth? Have there been any recorded fatalities?

As usual, Mythbusters to the rescue. They didn’t really test this but rather an adjacent conundrum of whether a bullet fired high up in the air might be…

Was selling Alaska to the USA a mistake by Russia?

Back in 1867, Russia had two choices with Alaska. World in 1857, ten years before the purchase, Alaska is a Russian territory Most Russian centers of population and…