Knowledge

Is the Phaethon asteroid going to make an impact with Earth on December 17th?

Yes it absolutely will, but not this year! Sometime, maybe on December 17th, or thereabouts in some undetermined year in the future it will definitely hit Earth and since it is about five kilometres in size, it will make quite a mess.

Bits of it will hit us this year. It is thought to be the source of the Geminid meteor shower, which you can see bombarding Earth if you go outside after midnight on December 14th this year, and every year in mid December.

This year the main body of 3200 Phaethon will miss us by about 10 million kilometres. It will come closer to earth on 14 December 2093, when the main body will pass at a distance of 2.9 million kilometres – still about 8 times further than the moon. The orbits of Earth and Phaethon are quite stable and will intersect for a long time into the future. But, its only about every 10 years that Phaethon happens to be in the part of its orbit that is close to Earth in mid December.

NASA has calculated the orbit over a 900 year period starting in 1600. The calculations are available at 3200 Phaethon. According to NASA it won’t hit us in the next 500 years, but beyond that its precise orbit gets more difficult to calculate.

The orbit is quite complex to calculate because besides close approaches to Earth, Phaethon also closely approaches Venus, Mercury and the asteroid 15 Eunomia. Small errors in the calculation could build to a significant change.

Phaethon appears to be inert, but it is suspected of being the nucleus of a comet which has lost its volatiles due to close approaches to the sun.

However if there are any volatiles left, the sun’s heat could cause them to outgas which could also change the orbit.

The date of Phaethon’s closest approach to Earth is slowly getting later in the year, as shown in the graph below.

As Ron Davis has pointed out to me, this is due to the precession of Earth’s rotational axis – which makes our calendar year 20 minutes shorter than a complete revolution of Earth around the sun.

Plotting the distance of the closest approaches according to NASA’s calculations, it appears to be getting closer – as shown below.

There are many reasons why this apparent correlation could be false, but if it is true, it indicates a collision on 31 December 3223. I am fairly sure that the NASA computationists would dispute my conclusion, but to be on the safe side, perhaps it’s time to start digging a shelter.

Also of note is that during December 2017, according to NASA NEO Earth Close Approaches, there were no fewer than 30 objects which came closer than 3200 Phaethon.
The closest of these was 2017 WV12, a 20 to 40 metre wide object which missed us by 1.6 million kilometres on 9 December.

Related Posts

What’s it like inside an aircraft carrier during a heavy storm?

During my time on a carrier, we went through a hurricane not once, but twice. We were in the Atlantic returning to our home port but first, we…

If the Soviets had decided to push the Allies out of Western Europe at the end of WW2, could they have done it?

Stalin asked Marshal Zhukov that very question in 1945. His answer: No. Westerns have a myth about the Red Army being this enormous inexhaustible machine that steamrolled its…

How long can an Ohio-class submarine stay submerged?

The Ohio-class nuclear submarine was designed for extended strategic deterrent patrols. Each submarine is assigned two complete crews, called the Blue crew and the Gold crew, each typically serving…

Why is the F-35 terribly flawed but the F-22 wasn’t?

The F-35 has been clubbing F-15s, F-16s, F-18s, like baby seals in recent exercises. And In Red Flag 17–1 when the F-35 was declared out of weapons, the…

How large can an aircraft carrier be made to accommodate as many aircraft as possible?

HMS Habakukk was planned to be 2000′ long, 300′ wide, and able to carry 200 planes including heavy bombers! While it was theoretically possible to build it, the…

Which US Navy jet was the most difficult or the easiest to land on the Aircraft Carrier?

Most difficult or worst? Almost certainly the Voight F7U Cutlass. 25% of the production run was lost to landing accident. Carrier Captains started ordering them off their ships…