Lifestyle

Is it true that if illegals are not counted, the Democrats would lose 10 House seats? How can illegals be counted in population when they are not legally in America?

Every state gets at least one seat in the House. Past that point, each seat represents about 750,000 people.

Here are the numbers of illegal immigrants in each state, per Pew Research, down to the point where they don’t influence the count of seats:

  • California (2.3 million) — blue state, 3 seats
  • Texas (2.1 million) — red state, 3 seats
  • Florida (1.6 million) — red state, 2 seats
  • New York (825,000) — blue state, 1 seat
  • New Jersey (600,000) — blue state, 1 seat
  • Illinois (550,000) — blue state, 1 seat, maybe

So, red states definitely get 5 seats from illegal immigrants. Blue states get at least 5, maybe 6.

IOW, it’s a draw.

The census counts people, not just citizens, because we need to know what sort of usage roads, bridges, utility systems, etc will get.

Note also that illegal immigrants paid $97 billion in taxes in 2022 and you don’t get utility service without paying for it, so they do pay for that infrastructure, as well as needing to use it.

The Constitution specifies that every ten years the entire population of the country is to be counted: it says “every person” resident in the country. Not every citizen, not every white person, not every voter, EVERY PERSON who resides in the country.

I’m sure that many illegals are not counted, as they will try to avoid notice, especially in the current fascist situation. Still, that’s what the Constitution stipulates, and what the algorithm that establishes House representatives is based on.

Related Posts

What sort of things horrify Europeans about U.S. culture?

I think what horrifies Europeans the most is that an actor who was the lead in a very popular 1990s US TV show, and starred in a series…

Why can’t I tell my deceased father’s bank that he died?

We learned our lesson when my father died. We advised the bank and they immediately froze the account, leaving my mother with nothing to live on. It was…

How did Canada issue a do not travel advisory on the United States?

Yeah, as someone from the US, I gotta say: this is getting fucking embarrassing. The US, at present, is hell. No other modern nation would have let itself…

What is the logic behind MAGA’s thinking that tariffs are good for America?

I was in a room full of my engineering managers. These are all highly educated, highly intelligent men who are quite capable of doing math. They are also,…

It’s 2am and I’m lost at sea. I see a ship on the horizon, and shoot a flare. The ship is the USS Nimitz. What happens on the carrier in order for me to be rescued if all the pilots are asleep?

Will the carrier assist even though I am not American? You have been under observation since long before you spotted the ship with your mark one eyeballs. You’ve…

Why are Americans so ignorant about the world?

I’m Canadian, but had to work as a Nurse in the USA for about 10yrs. I worked 2 different states. what i discovered from meeting teachers , and…