Knowledge

I’ve heard that a magnet can seriously damage an SD and hard drive. Is this true?

Once, the myth busters on the Discovery Channel dealt with this issue. They tried all kinds of the strong magnets, but none spoiled the hard drive in a laptop. But, when they exposed it to a commercial high powered magnet which is capable of lifting a car, the hard drive was entirely damaged. So the answer: it is unlikely to be damaged by any available magnet except the one used in shipyard to lift cars.

Unlike floppy discs, a hard drive has two big advantages. First is the magnetic flux density necessary to write a bit to the drive has increased as the bit density has increased. So even the degaussers sold commercially to bulk erase hard drives from some years back are not powerful enough to erase current drives.

Second advantage: it’s encased in metal. You could find a magnet large enough to corrupt or damage a hard drive, but you probably don’t own one. I ran into a benchtop superconducting electromagnet in a lab at MIT some years back.

It was recommended that these not be used near computers. And that car-lifting magnet the Mythbusters used is right out. Of course, a strong enough magnet might also fold, spindle, or otherwise mutilate the drive’s heads, bearings, etc.

An SD card stores data by trapping electrons within normally insulated transistor gates via Fowler–Nordheim tunneling. They are normally unaffected by the presence of a magnetic field.

It’s possible that, if you put an SD card into a very powerful varying magnetic field, you might induce electrical currents in the card that could corrupt the electrical charges stored on those FETs. But it’s also possible you’d damage the rest of the electronics on the card, such as the SD controller chip. Dead is dead, no matter how you arrange it.

I should point out, too, that I’m putting my money where my mouth is on this one. I have magentic mounts for my phone and tablet, both of which, of course, use flash memory for storage. After a couple of custom-made car mounts for specific phones, I switched to a small metal plate sticker on the back of the phone and a magnetic mount on my car’s console.

I have a little gizmo I made from a tripod ball head, magnets, and a thread adapter than lets me put my tablet up on a music stand, for an easy music read while playing guitar. I could pop that off, put the phone on, if I decided I wanted to shoot video at a music event instead.

Related Posts

Why do people think Ohio-class submarines have buoyancy issues after launching their SLBMs?

If an Ohio-class submarine launches its payload, it sheds over 2.6 million pounds in minutes. By the laws of physics, it should shoot to the surface like a…

Do submarines still have a big advantage over ships in war, or can ships find them and launch smart guided torpedoes from a safe distance?

During the time I served, if you asked a submariner what kind of ships did the Navy have, they would usually reply: submarines and targets. During one particular…

Is it better to inflate the tires a little more than recommended?

Will it make the tires last much longer? Why was I told this? Will it also make your tires more prone to blowing up if they are older…

Why do PCs gradually get slower with usage?

There’s 4 main reason for this, but only 2 of them are genuinely noticeable unless it’s a severe case of the latter reasons. Here are they by rank…

Do submarines hit things in the water?

Yes they do. There have been reports of submarines hitting whales, surface ships, and other submarines. Here’s a photo of the Los Angeles class USS San Francisco after…

Can U.S. aircraft carriers get bigger? Say 75 percent or two times bigger and than they are today as well as require less manpower to operate them? What are the pros and cons of this?

Can they? As in, is it theoretically possible with current engineering? Sure. Should they is another matter, and the answer to that is definitely no. If you look at the…