Knowledge

Why was the Moskva sunk so easily in spite of her considerable AA defense systems?

Moskva on paper had decent air defenses, but the hardware was all Cold War era stuff, not upgraded and possibly not even working.

That thing that looks like an ice cream cone on the back of the ship is the fire control radar, a 3R41 Volna, NATO code name “Top Dome” system for the ship’s S-300F missiles. The missiles themselves aren’t bad, but the radar set dates back from the early 80s. In pictures of the ship before it sank, the radar was in its idle position, which indicates it was either inoperative or not turned on.

At any rate, the fire control radar has a blind spot forward, where the Ukrainian cruise missiles impacted. The ship also does have point defense (both missiles and cannon) but if the incoming was not picked up on radar beforehand it likely wouldn’t be prepared.

There’s another wrinkle: these ships were actually built in Ukraine. In fact, there’s still an unfinished one sitting at the Mykolayiv Shipyard. Since the in-service units have seen very little modification, this means the Ukrainians knew everything about them including all the weaknesses of the design and exactly where to hit it to take it out.

Related Posts

Why do US Navy Nimitz-class and Ford-class aircraft carriers have cut outs near the bow that makes the deck shaped like a wine bottle instead of just a big rectangle with more parking space?

Those are not Cutouts. What you are looking at is the Angled Deck. It allows the Navy to conduct simultaneous Launch and recovery operations. Planes can be taking…

What is located on the bottom floor of an aircraft carrier?

I served aboard USS ABRAHAM LINCOLN (CVN72) as a machist mate a-gang. The lower and lowest decks are where the machinery spaces are. Additonally, there are fuel tanks…

Why is ‘double tapping’ by military personnel banned/illegal?

In Vietnam, as a tank driver, I remember some action near the Cambodian border in an area we called The Elephant Ear because on a map, it resembled…

What happened to all the “flak” shot at planes during war? Did it drop harmlessly to earth? Have there been any recorded fatalities?

As usual, Mythbusters to the rescue. They didn’t really test this but rather an adjacent conundrum of whether a bullet fired high up in the air might be…

Was selling Alaska to the USA a mistake by Russia?

Back in 1867, Russia had two choices with Alaska. World in 1857, ten years before the purchase, Alaska is a Russian territory Most Russian centers of population and…

From a geographical perspective, why is it said that Iran’s natural terrain is difficult to conquer?

From Alexander the Great to the Arab Empire, from the Mongol cavalry to the Ottoman army, and then to the Anglo-Russian rivalry in modern times and the encirclement…