Science

Can we nuke gas giant planets and wipe them out of solar system?

In 1992 a large comet was discovered that had recently been captured by Jupiter’s gravity. Jovian tidal forces had broken it into several pieces

It finally crashed into Jupiter in 1994.

The largest fragment impacted with an energy of 6 million megatons.

For comparison, the Tsar Bomba clocked in at 60 MT.

At the height of the Cold War, humanity possessed about 70,000 nukes.

If they were ALL Tsar Bombas, which of course they weren’t, the total megatonnage would be still just 4.2 million MT.

This is what Jupiter looked like after taking multiple multimillion megaton blasts:

You may notice that the planet is still there. Even the cloud band nearest to the impacts was barely disturbed, and the impact scars themselves were gone in about a week.

Addendum:

As this and related questions have been raised in the comments over the last little bit, here is a list of of examples of what it actually would take to permanently destroy Jupiter.

  1. A pile of Tsar Bomba nukes with a total mass of at least 4 times that of the moon
  2. A slug of pure antimatter at least half the mass of the Asteroid Juno.
  3. 158 years of the combined energy output of the sun
  4. The explosive power of one half solar mass of TNT (this would, of course, be fully capable of ripping Jupiter apart with gravitational tidal forces without needing to explode at all….)
  5. The total energy production of Human Civilization (as of 2018) for no less than 65 trillion years
  6. 9 hours worth of the total energy production of a K3 Galactic Civilization
  7. And, because in this universe, there is ALWAYS a bigger fish, 0.00000000001% of the total energy of a Type II Supernova.

Related Posts

According to Richard Feynman, gravity travels faster than light. If it did not, the torque would cause the planets to spiral out of the solar system. Is this correct?

If gravity takes time to reach Earth, we should be pulled toward where the Sun was 8 minutes ago. This delayed pull should fling us out of the solar system….

How does a missile find a submarine?

The anti-submarine missiles currently in service are best described as rocket propelled torpedoes. They are fired into the area where the submarine is, the torpedo detaches from the…

If you brought a Neanderthal baby to present-day and raised them normally, would they be any different? Could they learn as well or has the brain changed a lot?

While Neanderthals were genetically almost identical to us, as fellow erectus lineage cousins, the baby could probably be raised the same way. The problems would come during socialization….

If the Earth was to stop spinning for a full 3 seconds and then resume spinning, what would happen to everything on Earth and how would it be affected?

The world basically starts over. Plenty of life would remain but probably not many humans. Devastation is worse at the equator but pretty bad everywhere. Let’s break it…

Why is Earth’s rotation mysteriously slowing down?

It’s not mysterious at all. Newton predicted it hundreds of years before it could be directly measured. Basically, the Earth is slowing down because the Earth spins “beneath”…

What if the sun extinguished itself tonight? How long would humans survive?

If the sun went out, we would all eventually die, but what would kill us and how long would it take? First, once the sun is extinguished, the…