World

Why can’t Russia defeat Ukraine despite having 10 times military budget, 4 times manpower, and superior firepower?

Three key reasons, two minor and one large. The first minor reason is Russia also has about 5 times the corruption Ukraine has.

Wealthy Russians are wealthy for a reason

While yes, Russia has a massive advantage in war materiel, a lot of it goes down the pit of corruption. Ukraine has their own problems there, but they are somewhat smaller and thus Russia loses more to corruption. The second small reason is Ukraine is aided by the worlds’ foremost military powers and thus the Russian advantage in weapons and equipment is lessened substantially.

The major reason is Ukrainians know the alternative to war is death. Russians showed this very clearly in the opening days of war with mass rapes, murder, torture and wanton destruction. Towns taken by Russians are turned into dystopian hellholes for the survivors. Woe onto you if you don’t want to speak Russian or be a loyal Russian citizen. Children are taken away from their parents and fostered in Russia.

These are all war crimes and crimes against humanity, but Russians revel in it. That gives Ukrainians impetus to fight, at worst they die trying to prevent an even worse fate. Russians fight for money, their motivation are the large sign-up bonuses and promised wages that may never materialise. They do the bare minimum requried and try hard not to die.

Ukraine compounds this by prioritizing lower losses. Russians prioritize gains at all costs, leading to senseless assaults by poorly motivated, poorly trained forces that just leads to grotesque losses. Occasionally they score minor successes too, although I will notice their last victory of operational significance was over a year ago at this point. They used to take two operational goals per year, but haven’t yet delivered on one this year.

I’ll just quote what my immediate manager at Microsoft always said, whenever we discussed his managers:

Because they’re useless idiots.

There are mitigating circumstances here, though:

  • Russia has a military budget on paper, but in reality, huge amounts are embezzled.
  • Russian soldiers are fighting a war abroad for very unclear purposes, which is crap for morale.
  • The Russian military has, for decades, actively punished competence and rewarded incompetence, because the last thing Putin wanted was a competent military. They would inevitably realise that they were better at running the country than Putin and retire him out a window.

So there are at least reasons why they are useless idiots. They didn’t actually decide to be, they were head-hunted for uselessness.

Related Posts

Why is Russia always run by psychopaths, criminals, robbers, or other irresponsible people?

Everyone who lived in the Soviet Union and many today would immediately recognize this brutalsky reinforced concrete fence with diamond pattern. Its official name is PO-2 Fence Slab….

Why is the U.S. Navy’s Seawolf submarine such a top secret?

First I was on what submariners would call a target. And after having toured the Baton Rouge, short of Jesus coming and watching me sign papers to serve…

Will Trump eventually affect America’s standing in the world? As an American, it’s hard to get a read on what opinions are like abroad.

I’ve been following politics for more than 40 years and I’ve never seen anything like it. Up to 3 months ago, there were very fringe people in Canada…

How long will Canada make a show of standing firm against US tariffs before they inevitably capitulate and willingly become the 51st state?

Why haven’t the Republicans thought this through? Canada has roughly 40 million people – about the same population as California. If Canada became the 51st state (there’s a…

Is China good at copying?

I have a friend who works for TSMC. She has an American PhD in Engineering. One day some years ago, I asked her do you think the Chinese…

Israel has lost 3 F-35s over Iran in less than 24 hours. Is the F- 35 obsolete?

Iranian state media reported that their air defense systems successfully downed three Israeli F-35 fighter jets. They also stated that one of the pilots was captured after ejecting…