World

Why did communism fail everywhere except in China?

Because Communism failed in China before it did anywhere else.

Great leap forward, 20–100 million dead

Communism failed China so badly it was as relevant to the world stage as perhaps Pakistan is today: a nuisance for the neighbors perhaps, but not more. Yet China wanted more, it wanted to become the leader of the Communist world.

When it became clear the Soviets would have none of that they had to make a choice: either accept Soviet dominance and submit to the Russian Communist Party, or open up with the USA and change.

They did the sensible thing.

Nixon in China

China remained nominally Communist but in practice they’ve been anything but since 1970s. Their system right now most resembles that of 1920s Italy or 1930s Germany, which is many things, but even ardent anti-Communists would agree it is not Communism.


A famous political joke goes as such:

The American came to two roads that lead to 2 places. One sign reads “communism”, and the other one read “capitalism”, and went straight to “capitalism”.

Stalin came around, and went straight to “Communism”.

Then Chairman Deng came around, switched the signs, and went towards the one that read “Communism”.

The truth about The Market, is that neither totally free or totally controlled market would ever work. The U.S.S.R. and the U.S. have proven that. Completely free markets result in Social Darwinism: the rich get richer, and the poor get poorer.

Completely controlled markets lead to the opposite of control: complete hunger and lower life standards. China took the road down the middle. It’s hard, for anybody, or China, in this case. Economics has never been easy.

China is currently carefully balancing between “control” and “free market”. A slight lean towards one side may cause a lot of problems.

Related Posts

Why is Russia always run by psychopaths, criminals, robbers, or other irresponsible people?

Everyone who lived in the Soviet Union and many today would immediately recognize this brutalsky reinforced concrete fence with diamond pattern. Its official name is PO-2 Fence Slab….

Why is the U.S. Navy’s Seawolf submarine such a top secret?

First I was on what submariners would call a target. And after having toured the Baton Rouge, short of Jesus coming and watching me sign papers to serve…

Will Trump eventually affect America’s standing in the world? As an American, it’s hard to get a read on what opinions are like abroad.

I’ve been following politics for more than 40 years and I’ve never seen anything like it. Up to 3 months ago, there were very fringe people in Canada…

How long will Canada make a show of standing firm against US tariffs before they inevitably capitulate and willingly become the 51st state?

Why haven’t the Republicans thought this through? Canada has roughly 40 million people – about the same population as California. If Canada became the 51st state (there’s a…

Is China good at copying?

I have a friend who works for TSMC. She has an American PhD in Engineering. One day some years ago, I asked her do you think the Chinese…

Israel has lost 3 F-35s over Iran in less than 24 hours. Is the F- 35 obsolete?

Iranian state media reported that their air defense systems successfully downed three Israeli F-35 fighter jets. They also stated that one of the pilots was captured after ejecting…