Science

If a planet could successfully orbit a black hole without being harmed, what would the sky look like from its surface?

I think this question is another example of how badly black holes are misunderstood.

Suppose we replaced the Sun with a black hole of the same mass. It would have two consequences:

First, the Earth would continue to orbit exactly as before. The thing about gravity is that it doesn’t matter what does the pulling: two things of the same mass will produce the same amount of gravity. So the Earth’s orbit doesn’t change so long as the mass of the central object doesn’t change.

Second, the sky would be dark, apart from the stars. Where the Sun would be, you’d see nothing. The black hole’s event horizon is only a few kilometers across, and any weird optical effects due to its strong gravity are confined to a region not much larger… far too small to see, never mind the naked eye, even with a large telescope.

So it’s as though there was nothing where the Sun used to be. You’d see the stars just fine, in that and every other direction. You would not see the Moon of course, since there is no sunlight for it to reflect… and you would not see any planets, for the same reason.

And of course, in short order, Earth’s weather would start to go berserk, the oceans would freeze over, and within a few months at the most, life on the surface of our planet would come to an end as nitrogen snow falls from the cold sky. But that is simply due to the lack of sunshine, not due to anything the black hole does.


Related Posts

Why is the speed of light so slow?

I have never figured this out either and the first time I worked out how slow light actually travels was kind of an epiphany. It’s not that it’s…

According to Richard Feynman, gravity travels faster than light. If it did not, the torque would cause the planets to spiral out of the solar system. Is this correct?

If gravity takes time to reach Earth, we should be pulled toward where the Sun was 8 minutes ago. This delayed pull should fling us out of the solar system….

How does a missile find a submarine?

The anti-submarine missiles currently in service are best described as rocket propelled torpedoes. They are fired into the area where the submarine is, the torpedo detaches from the…

If you brought a Neanderthal baby to present-day and raised them normally, would they be any different? Could they learn as well or has the brain changed a lot?

While Neanderthals were genetically almost identical to us, as fellow erectus lineage cousins, the baby could probably be raised the same way. The problems would come during socialization….

Can we nuke gas giant planets and wipe them out of solar system?

In 1992 a large comet was discovered that had recently been captured by Jupiter’s gravity. Jovian tidal forces had broken it into several pieces It finally crashed into…

If the Earth was to stop spinning for a full 3 seconds and then resume spinning, what would happen to everything on Earth and how would it be affected?

The world basically starts over. Plenty of life would remain but probably not many humans. Devastation is worse at the equator but pretty bad everywhere. Let’s break it…